Skip to main content

Marriage takes work. But at what point is it time to call it quits? Here are 15 signs from divorce attorneys that your marriage may be beyond repair.

Getting a divorce is a difficult decision that many couples face. While every marriage will have its ups and downs, there comes a point when the bad may outweigh the good. If you’re wondering whether your marriage can be saved—or whether it’s time to separate—here are some signs that divorce might be the healthiest option for you and your spouse.

Here are 15 Signs that You Should Separate From Your Husband:

1. You Have Tried Marriage Counseling Without Success

Seeking professional marriage counseling is often couples’ first step when they hit a rough patch. The fact that you’ve already tried this route without seeing any real improvements is a major red flag.

Counseling can be incredibly effective at mending cracks in a marriage – but only if both people are willing to put in the work. If you gave counseling a fair shot for several months but saw no changes in your husband’s hurtful behaviors or no improvement in how you relate to each other, it likely means some foundational aspects of your marriage are broken beyond repair.

2. Your Trust Has Been Completely Shattered

Trust is the bedrock of any healthy marriage. When that trust has been broken – especially through serious breaches like infidelity, financial dishonesty, or addiction – it can be impossible to rebuild.

If your husband has betrayed your trust and you are unable to move past it, that is an understandable reason why separation may be the next step. The broken trust may have created resentment, pain, and distance that is insurmountable no matter how much counseling you try.

3. You and Your Husband Bring Out the Worst in Each Other

There is an old saying that you should marry your best friend. But what happens when your spouse starts to feel like your enemy?

Unhealthy relationships can become breeding grounds for constant criticism, belittling comments, explosive arguments, manipulation, and other toxic behaviors. If you and your husband are stuck in a dynamic where you frequently hurt each other verbally and emotionally, it may be time to call it quits. Living in constant conflict is miserable for you both.

4. You Have Fallen Out of Love

Falling out of love with your spouse is a legitimate reason to question continuing the marriage. Love is the glue that holds a marriage together through life’s ups and downs. Without it, you may start to feel lonely, disconnected, and unsatisfied.

If your feelings for your husband have faded and you have lost the intimacy that once bonded you together, separation allows you both the chance to find partners you connect with on a deeper level.

5. Your Husband Refuses to Work on the Marriage

As the old saying goes, it takes two to tango. If you have tried addressing your marital problems directly with your husband or through counseling, but he refuses to acknowledge issues or make any effort to fix them, you are likely headed toward divorce.

One partner cannot revive a struggling marriage alone. For counseling and communication to work, your husband has to be equally invested in the hard work of understanding your concerns, compromising, and making changes to improve your dynamic. If he is checked out or unwilling to try, separation frees you from a dead-end marriage.

6. You Have Grown Apart and Want Different Things

Over the years, especially after major life changes like having kids, it is common for spouses to grow apart rather than together. Your priorities, interests, goals, and values no longer align with your husband’s.

Maybe you hoped to travel together in your 40s after the kids move out, but he wants to immediately become a grandparent. Or perhaps faith has become central in your life while your spouse is now an adamant atheist. Incompatible visions for the future are red flags that separation may be imminent.

7. There Is Abuse in Your Marriage

If there is any kind of abuse – verbal, emotional, physical, or sexual – in your marriage, your safety has to come first. Talk to trusted friends and family about what is happening and contact domestic violence resources like the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233.

No one deserves to endure abuse. Though counseling is often recommended, it may be unsafe if your spouse is volatile or controlling. Getting to safety and seeking legal separation is recommended in cases of domestic violence or intimate partner abuse.

8. You Feel Like Roommates, Not Spouses

Do you and your husband feel more like polite roommates or co-parents sharing space rather than two people in an intimate relationship? If all romance and passion has fizzled out of your marriage, it is likely nearing the end of its lifespan.

Without intimacy binding you together – both emotional and physical – you may start questioning why you are still married at all. Living together for logistics while emotionally detaching from your spouse means separation could be on the horizon.

9. You Have Feelings for Someone Else

Finding yourself attracted to or emotionally invested in someone outside of your marriage is a serious red flag. Though falling for a flirtatious coworker or your spouse’s charming friend likely does not mean you want to end your marriage, it may indicate underlying problems.

If you are craving the intellectual and emotional connection you have with this person, it could signify your needs are not being met within your marriage. Even if you do not act on it, the attraction may be a wake up call that separation is inevitable.

10. Your Spouse Seems Happier When You Are Apart

Do you notice your husband seems lighter, less stressed, and generally happier when you are not around? Does he dote on the kids, extended family, and friends yet seem to withdraw from you?

A spouse who is relieved to be away from you and thriving when you are not together is sending the message that your marriage has broken down. Though it may be painful to accept, separation could be a welcome change for you both.

11. You Are Constantly Fighting About the Same Issues

Being stuck in a negative cycle where you and your spouse fight about the same topics over and over with no resolution is draining. These could be arguments about money, intimacy, parenting disagreements, or other serious issues that continue to drive a wedge between you no matter how many times you clash.

At some point, you have to step back and recognize that continuing the status quo and staying together may be worse than separating. If your arguments are filled with contempt, stonewalling, and defensiveness and you have hit an impasse, a time apart could be the wake up call your marriage needs.

12. You Don’t Have Shared Values or Life Goals Anymore

As you grow and change throughout your life, your priorities, interests, and values can shift over time. But when you and your spouse no longer see eye to eye on the big things that make up shared dreams and goals, trouble may lie ahead.

If your visions of the future no longer have common threads – for example, you want to retire abroad but your husband is adamant about staying local – trying to force a shared path usually ends badly. Separating allows you each to find partners whose goals and values better complement your own.

13. You Are Questioning Your Commitment

If you have found yourself frequently wondering whether you made the right decision marrying your husband or if you would be happier alone, pay attention – these could be signs your commitment to the marriage is wavering.

You do not need a massive blow-out fight or shocking event to realize you have fallen out of love. Noticing you cringe when your spouse touches you or you are embarrassed to bring him to work functions signals something is off. If you have tried to deny it but cannot shake your doubts about staying with him long-term, separation may be the inevitable next step.

14. You Have Drifted Into Different Social Circles

Couples who once spent meaningful time together connecting with friends may realize their social lives have completely separated. Your friends are not fond of your husband, and he refuses to join you on girls’ nights. He hangs out with his college buddies often, but you feel unwelcome.

If your once overlapping social circle has evaporated and you now inhabit totally separate worlds, your emotional connection has likely fizzled as well. Separating allows you to rebuild friendships and support systems as individuals, which is essential.

15. You Are Miserable More Often Than Not

At the end of the day, the most important question is: are you happy? Do you feel loved, respected, supported, and satisfied in your marriage the majority of the time? Or are you more often left feeling neglected, lonely, frustrated, or depressed?

Being in an unhealthy marriage takes a huge toll, both emotionally and physically. Listen to what your mind, body, and inner voice are telling you. If the thought of continuing your marriage fills you with dread, anxiety, or despair, it may be time to seriously look into separation for the sake of your mental and emotional well-being.

How a MN Divorce Attorney Can Help Navigate Separation

If after reading through these signs you feel ready to initiate separation from your husband, you should speak with a knowledgeable Minnesota divorce lawyer.

At Martine Law, our caring Minnesota divorce attorneys are here to support and counsel you through this difficult transition. With offices across the Twin Cities metro, we help men and women navigate separation and divorce with dignity.

Our lawyers take time to understand your unique situation. We will determine whether a legal separation, pursuing mediation, or going straight to divorce is the right route. With sensitivity and care, we aim to make the process as amicable and stress-free as possible.

We know this is an incredibly painful crossroads. You deserve compassionate legal guidance tailored to your needs. To learn more about how we can help or schedule a consultation, contact Martine Law today.