Reviewed by the Marketing Team Last updated
A missing document, disputed witness account, or plea offer does not by itself prove that a criminal case is weak. A useful assessment compares the admissible evidence with each element of the charged offense. The stage of the case matters: probable cause to proceed is different from proof beyond a reasonable doubt at trial.
Under Minnesota Statutes section 611.02, a defendant is presumed innocent and is entitled to acquittal when reasonable doubt remains. You do not have to prove actual innocence to hold the prosecution to its burden.
1. Questions About Probable Cause
Ask counsel what facts support the charge and whether a probable-cause challenge is available. Minnesota Rule of Criminal Procedure 11 addresses probable-cause and other pretrial motions in felony and gross misdemeanor cases. A challenge to an arrest is not automatically a dismissal of the charge.
2. Gaps in Proof of an Offense
Identify what the prosecution must prove and which evidence addresses each element. Missing DNA, fingerprints, video, or a chemical test does not automatically defeat a case; other evidence may matter. Review the complete record before drawing a conclusion from one missing item.
3. Material Inconsistencies in Witness Accounts
Compare statements with recordings, documents, and the timeline. Discuss inconsistencies, possible bias, and opportunities to observe with counsel. A witness’s background or an inconsistency does not automatically make all testimony unreliable. Avoid contacting witnesses to influence their account.
4. Questions About Admissibility
A lawyer can assess whether to challenge how evidence was obtained or whether it may be used at trial. Rule 11 provides for constitutional and evidentiary issues to be heard before trial. A request to exclude evidence is different from an order excluding it, and exclusion of one item does not necessarily end the prosecution.
5. Errors in the Charging Document
Bring incorrect names, dates, alleged acts, or statutory references to your lawyer’s attention. Their legal significance depends on the error. Rules 17.05 and 17.06 allow certain amendments and distinguish defects affecting substantial rights from harmless matters of form. A typo is not a reliable sign of dismissal.
6. Disputes About Defense Evidence
An objection to a defense witness or exhibit does not reveal the prosecutor’s confidence. Ask counsel what the objection concerns, how to respond, and what ruling the court has made. Evaluate the evidence and the ruling rather than assuming an objection proves the case is weak.
7. A Plea Offer That Needs Careful Evaluation
A plea offer is not proof that the prosecutor is bluffing. Before accepting or rejecting it, discuss the evidence, possible defenses, trial risks, proposed terms, and consequences beyond the sentence. Do not base this decision on a checklist or a prediction from an online article.
What to Bring to a Defense Consultation
- Your charging documents, hearing notices, and release conditions.
- A dated timeline separating what you personally observed from what someone told you.
- Unaltered messages, photographs, and recordings you lawfully possess.
- Questions about missing records, witnesses, deadlines, and the next hearing.
Keep scheduled court appearances and follow release conditions while concerns are reviewed. Tell your attorney promptly about evidence that may disappear, such as video that could be overwritten.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to prove I am innocent?
No. The presumption of innocence and the prosecution’s burden remain central. Discuss any specific defense and its requirements with your attorney.
Does a mistake in a police report mean dismissal?
No. Identify the mistake and any supporting records for counsel. Its significance depends on what it affects; an error is not an automatic outcome.
How can I find out whether my case has a real weakness?
Ask your lawyer to connect the available evidence to the charged elements, explain unresolved issues, and distinguish possible motions from rulings already made.
Discuss Your Minnesota Criminal Case
A Minnesota criminal defense attorney can review your documents and explain the next steps. Contact Martine Law to discuss your situation. No case assessment guarantees dismissal, acquittal, or a reduced charge.
This page provides general Minnesota legal information, not advice for a particular case.
