Arguments happen. But when tempers flare and voices rise, you might wonder if simply yelling during a heated disagreement could land you in legal trouble. In Minnesota, the answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no.
While yelling itself is not a crime, the context and content of your words, combined with the situation, can quickly escalate things and result in an arrest. At Martine Law, we’ve seen firsthand how domestic disputes or emotional confrontations can spiral into criminal charges—even when no physical violence occurred.
If you’re worried about whether yelling could result in criminal charges, here’s what you need to know.
Yelling Alone Isn’t Illegal—But It Can Cross the Line
Under Minnesota law, yelling or raising your voice isn’t automatically a crime. The First Amendment protects your right to free speech. However, if yelling involves threats, intimidation, or causes someone to fear for their safety, it may fall into legally actionable territory.
Here are a few scenarios where yelling could lead to arrest:
- Making verbal threats of harm
- Yelling during a domestic dispute where the other person feels endangered
- Disturbing the peace in public or during nighttime hours
- Obstructing law enforcement or refusing to comply during an investigation
In these cases, law enforcement can arrest you even if there was no physical contact.
Common Charges That May Stem from Yelling
Several criminal charges in Minnesota can apply to situations involving heated verbal arguments, including:
1. Disorderly Conduct
Under Minnesota Statute § 609.72, disorderly conduct includes engaging in “offensive, obscene, abusive, boisterous, or noisy conduct” that disturbs the peace. Yelling during an argument, especially in public or in front of others, can sometimes qualify.
Penalty: Misdemeanor with up to 90 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.
2. Domestic Assault – Verbal Threats
Minnesota’s domestic assault law does not require physical contact. Yelling combined with verbal threats or causing fear in a household or family member can lead to arrest.
Even saying something like “I’m going to hurt you” in anger can be considered a criminal threat under domestic assault statutes.
Penalty: Misdemeanor to felony, depending on history and circumstances.
3. Terroristic Threats
Making threats to commit violence, even if not carried out, may result in a charge of terroristic threats under Minnesota Statute § 609.713. This includes statements like “I’ll kill you” or “I’m going to burn this place down.”
Penalty: Felony with up to 5 years in prison.
Police Response to Domestic Disputes
Minnesota has mandatory arrest policies for domestic violence situations. If police respond to a call and believe a crime has been committed—even if it’s only verbal—they may make an arrest without a warrant.
Here’s what can happen:
- Police separate the parties and conduct brief interviews
- If they believe probable cause exists for a threat or fear of harm, one party may be arrested
- Protective orders or no-contact conditions may be issued on the spot
This is why it’s crucial to remain calm, avoid escalating the argument, and contact a lawyer immediately if arrested or charged.
Does the Other Person Need to Press Charges?
No. In domestic cases, the state prosecutes the case—not the alleged victim. Even if the other person wants to “drop the charges,” it’s up to the prosecutor to decide whether the case moves forward.
This is important because you could face long-term consequences even if the person you argued with didn’t want you arrested.
Can You Be Arrested Without Physical Violence?
Yes. Minnesota law allows for arrests based solely on words or behavior that cause fear, intimidation, or disruption. Many people are surprised to learn that:
- Yelling in front of children may trigger a child endangerment investigation
- Loud arguments in an apartment can lead to disorderly conduct arrests
- Arguments during custody exchanges may involve police intervention
If the incident is classified under domestic violence laws, it can also impact family court outcomes, including custody and visitation.
Legal Defenses for Verbal Disputes
If you’re facing charges stemming from an argument, several legal defenses may apply:
- Lack of intent to threaten
- No actual fear caused to the other person
- Protected speech under the First Amendment
- False or exaggerated accusations
- Insufficient evidence
At Martine Law, we review police reports, interview witnesses, and gather audio or video evidence (if available) to present your side clearly in court.
What to Do If You’re Arrested
If you’re arrested for yelling during an argument or a related verbal offense:
- Do not argue with law enforcement or attempt to explain yourself on the spot
- Do not contact the alleged victim, even to apologize, if a no-contact order is in place
- Document your version of events, including witnesses, texts, or other communications
- Speak to an experienced criminal defense attorney immediately
These steps can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case.
Long-Term Consequences of Verbal Charges
Being convicted of a verbal offense like disorderly conduct or domestic assault can lead to:
- A permanent criminal record
- Difficulty finding housing or employment
- Loss of child custody or parenting time
- Loss of gun rights, in cases of domestic violence
That’s why taking these charges seriously—and getting legal representation—is critical.
Let Martine Law Help
At Martine Law, we understand that emotions run high and that one argument shouldn’t define your future. If you’ve been arrested after a verbal dispute, we’ll help protect your rights and fight for the best possible resolution.
Schedule your confidential consultation today and let us stand in your corner.
Helpful Resources: